Image from Unsplash
As the 2025 Major League Soccer season hits its midpoint, the betting landscape has shifted dramatically. Teams that began the season as long shots are climbing, while preseason favorites stumble. With playoff races tightening and top scorers catching fire, bettors are recalibrating their strategies.
Using mid-season data from both conferences, we’ll unpack which clubs are surging in betting markets and which are falling off. This deep dive doesn’t just spotlight standings but also unveils scoring trends, playoff positioning, and high-impact players shaping wagers across the league.
Eastern Conference: Powerhouses and Pitfalls
As the MLS season unfolds, the Eastern Conference offers a wide spectrum of betting potential—from dominant frontrunners to volatile middle-tier teams and those struggling to stay relevant. Here’s a breakdown of where the value lies.
Top Contenders: Philadelphia and Cincinnati Lead the Way
Philadelphia Union and FC Cincinnati continue to fuel bettor confidence. Philadelphia sits atop the East with 40 points, built on 12 wins and a league-leading +15 goal difference. Tai Baribo’s 13 goals boost their offensive punch, making them consistent favorites in moneyline bets and over/under goal totals.
Cincinnati trails by just a point, their potent attack producing 31 goals. Kévin Denkey and Evander, both tallying 11 goals each, are creating havoc in opposing boxes. Their ability to draw or snatch late wins appeals to spread bettors seeking narrow-margin plays.
Nashville’s Star Power: Straight Bet Reliability
Nashville SC, anchored by Sam Surridge’s 16 goals—the highest in MLS—presents strong player prop value. Their 38 points and solid +13 goal difference make them appealing in straight bets, especially given their sturdy defense.
Goal Machines: Columbus and Orlando Deliver Returns
Columbus Crew and Orlando City SC round out the top five, each showing betting value with their goal-scoring efficiency. Columbus leans on Diego Rossi’s nine goals and Diego Rossi’s creativity in attack, while Orlando features a three-headed scoring monster: Marco Pasalic, Martín Ojeda, and Luis Muriel. Bettors backing their matches are seeing high returns in goal-heavy markets.
Middle-Tier Chaos: Value in Variability
The middle of the East is crowded with unpredictable sides. Inter Miami CF, now driven by Lionel Messi’s 10 goals and Luis Suárez’s league-best eight assists, are inconsistent in results but enticing in player props. Their defense remains suspect, but few teams offer as much attacking firepower.
New York Red Bulls, Chicago Fire FC, and New York City FC all sit tightly packed. Eric Maxim Choupo-Moting’s 11 goals for New York Red Bulls elevate their betting appeal, while Chicago’s Hugo Cuypers and Philip Zinckernagel offer consistent offensive threats. New York City FC is fueled by Hannes Wolf and Alonso Martínez, making them high-variance but tempting picks.
Slipping Stocks: Charlotte and New England Fade
Bettors are fading clubs like Charlotte FC and New England Revolution, with inconsistent offenses and fragile defenses. Both have talented players—Pep Biel and Carles Gil—but their teams rarely cover spreads or deliver in tight contests.
Bottom of the Table: High Risk, Low Reward
D.C. United, Toronto FC, Atlanta United FC, and CF Montréal are firmly in the betting basement. Their weak defenses and toothless attacks make them risky even as underdogs. Only Christian Benteke at D.C. United and Emmanuel Latte Lath at Atlanta offer glimmers of betting relevance.
Western Conference: Surprise Contenders and Slipping Giants
The Western Conference is shaking up expectations for bettors in 2025. From expansion surprises to veteran teams falling flat, here’s how the current standings impact betting strategy.
San Diego’s Shock Rise: First-Year Goldmine
San Diego FC and Vancouver Whitecaps are redefining the Western betting picture. San Diego, a first-year surprise, tops the West with 39 points, tied for the best goal difference (+16). Anders Dreyer, with nine goals and a league-leading 13 assists, has become a darling in anytime scorer and assist markets.
Milan Iloski and Hirving Lozano also contribute consistently, making San Diego matches among the league’s highest in total goals wagers. Unsurprisingly, San Diego’s rise has shaken up the Major League Soccer betting odds across many sportsbooks.
Vancouver’s Balance: Defense Meets Value
Vancouver isn’t far behind, powered by Brian White’s 10 goals and Ali Ahmed’s playmaking. Their defense is stout, but bettors find value in both totals and Vancouver to win markets.
Minnesota’s Underrated Efficiency
Minnesota United FC, with 34 points and a +10 goal difference, finds themselves a quiet favorite for sharp bettors. Tani Oluwaseyi and Kelvin Yeboah are delivering in player props, while their matches often deliver for over bettors.
Consistent Contenders: Portland and Seattle Stay in the Mix
Portland Timbers and Seattle Sounders FC remain steady performers in betting circles. David Da Costa and Antony lead Portland’s attack, providing options for first goal scorer bets. Seattle leans on Albert Rusnák and Jesús Ferreira, both reliable in assists and goal markets.
Unpredictable Players: San Jose and LAFC Keep Bettors Guessing
San Jose Earthquakes and LAFC are wild cards. Cristian Arango’s 10 goals and Cristian Espinoza’s 10 assists make San Jose matches among the most unpredictable for bettors. LAFC, led by Denis Bouanga, continue to attract attention but with inconsistent returns.
Playoff Fringe: Colorado and Austin Offer Mixed Value
Colorado Rapids and Austin FC both hover at the playoff line, with their results swinging wildly. Djordje Mihailovic leads Colorado’s attack, while Austin’s Brandon Vázquez has limited upside. Bettors approach these sides cautiously, often targeting individual player props instead.
Sliding Out of Contention: Betting Risk Increases
Houston Dynamo FC, FC Dallas, Sporting Kansas City, and Real Salt Lake slide further down the table, delivering poor returns in traditional markets. Petar Musa for Dallas and Dejan Joveljic for Sporting KC provide rare bright spots for goalscorer wagers. However, these teams often fail to cover spreads, frustrating backers.
Bottomed Out: St. Louis and LA Galaxy Struggle to Attract Bets
St. Louis CITY SC and LA Galaxy sit at the bottom. Their defensive struggles and ineffective offenses render them almost unplayable, even in heavy underdog spots. Marco Reus’s modest assist tally is one of the few betting angles for Galaxy supporters.
Star Power Shaping Bets
In 2025, it’s not just team performance influencing betting trends—individual players are becoming game-changers in their own right. From top scorers to playmakers, star power is redefining how bettors find value in MLS markets.
Goal Scorers Leading the Way
This season isn’t just about teams—individual brilliance is driving massive shifts in betting markets. Sam Surridge’s 16 goals make him the hottest commodity for anytime scorer wagers, particularly given Nashville’s balanced play. His impact on totals markets is equally strong, pushing over lines higher in Nashville games.
Dual-Threat Playmakers
Anders Dreyer’s 13 assists, alongside nine goals, position him as a two-way threat. Bettors backing San Diego benefit from both his scoring and passing prowess, elevating same-game parlay opportunities.
Messi’s Betting Magnetism
Messi, despite playing fewer matches, still reshapes the board. His 10 goals and seven assists for Inter Miami make him a constant draw in prop bets, especially given his chemistry with Luis Suárez.
Rising Names in the Player Watch
FanDuel’s MLS player watch highlights other names climbing betting charts, including Kévin Denkey, Evander, Eric Maxim Choupo-Moting, and Diego Rossi. These players fuel offensive fireworks, pushing both over bets and individual prop bets into profitable territory.
Why Player Markets Matter
For bettors seeking edges beyond moneylines, these player markets often present better value than team markets. FanDuel and other sportsbooks routinely adjust odds around these stars, making early wagers key.
Navigating the Second Half
With playoff races tightening, Philadelphia and San Diego look set to remain top targets, while player props—especially around stars like Surridge and Dreyer—continue to offer strong value. Mid-tier clubs like Minnesota, Columbus, and Orlando present steady returns, especially in totals and spreads. Bettors fading struggling teams such as St. Louis CITY, LA Galaxy, and Montréal still find reliable opportunities. As the season unfolds, staying sharp and adapting to trends will be key.
